20 Pack Extra Thick Magic Cleaning Pads - Eraser Sponge for All Surfaces - Kitchen-Bathroom-Furniture-Leather-Car-Steel - Just Add Water to Erase All Dirt - Melamine - Universal Cleaner

They mostly do the job but I don’t think they are quite as effective or durable as Mr. Ckean Magic erasers. However, this makes them my go-to for wall stains or other delicate surfaces such as wood (Mr. Clean takes the paint off my walls, these remove stains but don’t remove paint). I’ve successfully removed sharpie from the wall and a desk (thanks to my budding artist 4 year-old) without damaging either surface. They are k in thicker than the Magic clean eraser. I personally feel like they are a little bulky and prefer the more compact feel of Mr. Clean. Also, these don’t do as well for heavier stains (such as burned on stains on the stovetop) as the Magic Eraser does. I find that they fall apart when trying to clean stains like these and don’t last as long. That being said, they are a really good deal for the money!

I bought this product with the intention of cleaning a couple of pots that had hard yellow stains from grease on the inside and outside. It worked perfectly and without a lot of scrubbing effort. In addition to that, we have white walls in all rooms and there are a few areas with our childs art so I was able to get off the crayon, pencil crayon and pen marks that had been made along with black furniture scuff marks. I got off some recent hard water stains from the bathroom but older ones that had accumulate didnt come off but I think they could almost come off with a little more effort. I viewed a couple of videos on what this amazing magic sponge can do and it truly is amazing. I cant believe I havent had it in my life until now, its that good.

I originally got these erasers for pesky marks on my walls, which they do work but I’ve found them tremendously more useful to clean my clients’ and my own bathtub and showers! It truly cuts through any grime or soup buildup. It does not, however, get rid of hard water stains but that’s okay there’s other methods out there. For the price you get and the amount I can’t complain. If you squeeze too hard or dig your fingers into them when scrubbing they do tear very easily, but I’ve learned my lesson and try to handle better so they last longer.

These work great on soap scum in the shower, limescale around faucets, hardened toothpaste in the bathroom sink, etc. And theyre much cheaper than the name brand. They seem like they start coming apart really fast, though - I can easily use one per sink if the mess is bad. Even so, I would buy these again.

While I read the relative sizes when deciding which pack of off-brand magic erasers to get, I didnt realize just how big these sponges would be. These are easily twice the size of the original and the entire pack of twenty is roughly the size of three big hard-back books stacked. When the original brand is 2 dollars for 2, and these are 9 dollars for 20 (at twice the size), even if it werent working comparably, Id still call it a deal. I ripped mine in half so I could clean more easily with it. If you have big hands, then they might fit better. As other reviews state, Ive used these to get off those really stubborn stains that wont come off otherwise. For me, it was yellow/orange marks on the bottom of the toilet seat. Bath and tile cleaner and scrubbing didnt work, but these sponges managed it with a little elbow grease!

These aren’t as good as the name brand for sure!

Great value

Wow! WOW! I bought a 20 pack of these for I think less than a 6 pack of Mr cleans magic erasers. Why? Because everytime I tried to use the mr clean eraser, it would literally fall apart within 5 seconds of use. For years, like an insane person, I just kept buying more hoping things would be different. I probably could’ve achieved more durable cleaning results by just using actual dollar bills. That’s how bad it was. Don’t get me wrong, the magic erasers worked, but they fell apart so quickly I sometimes had to use two or three just to clean my bathtub. That adds up. I randomly stumbled across this “magic cleaners” and I figured what the heck they can’t possibly be WORSE than mr clean magic erasers, and if they are, at least it’s a 20 pack. Just wow! I’m so glad I decided to try these instead! They definitely are extra thick as advertised and more importantly, they don’t fall apart!! Like honestly I cleaned my bathroom doors and still have a full pad. I kept expecting it to disintegrate like Mr clean but nooope! This is the first time in my experience where a “generic” product worked 10x better than a name brand product. Thank you guys for creating such a great product and for respecting your customers hard earned money!

After finding out that Mr. Clean Magic Eraser was just a Melamine sponge with some detergent, I decided to purchase something with more quantity out of the same material for less money. It does the job and cleans just as well, but the texture is very different from Mr. Clean and its made in a way where its easily snaps in half. About three of them have snapped already, while the Mr Clean Melamine sponges have never snapped and are much more reusable because of it. At least I got twice the amount than what comes in a Mr Clean Sponge pack for the same price, which should make up for the lack of quality. I wont be buying these again. I wish I could return them, but its too late since I obviously needed to open the package to use the sponges, and I dont think Amazon would appreciate a package with missing items in it.

These held up so much better than another major brand. How I used it was to loosen the marks of whatever kind on my walls and doors and wiped clean with a damp microfiber cloth. It was amazing. Things that the other brand didnt get off nor did my microfiber. So dont freak if the sponge looks like its smearing the dirt. Thats the point the damp microfiber gets used! Its addictive!!!