Coleman Tie-Style Mantle, 4-Pack

Fast delivery. Item as promised. Great buy.

My items kept burning up. Im sure it was something I was doing something wrong.

Easy to install, worked great

Great!

fast s&h, great product.

I have only used genuine Coleman mantles in the past, and have always had success. But with this new pack, the first mantle bag I lit burned down to ash (as they are supposed to), but with two tears in the ashed bag. So I had to start over. The second bag burned to ash perfectly without any tears and it lights up brightly. This is a 4-pack, so I have two mantles left. Assuming the next two mantles will be okay when needed, that would mean a 25% failure rate. A 75% success rate (assumed) would not be good enough for 5 stars. So 3 stars seem to be the appropriate rating. I have read there are other mantles which are stronger, but which may emit radiation. So, until I find a better solution, Ill stick with Coleman, for now, and hope that this was a fluke and not an indication of any change of quality.

must have for camping lantern.

These things looked enormous when I took them out of the package, but once you light it for the first time it shrinks down to normal size. We have only used them for one camping trip so far, but they worked like a champ.

Same old mantles they have always been. I usually spend the extra dollar and get the clip on version though. These are a little hard to get on if you don’t have nimble fingers.

love these, they will burn all year!